| 3:13 PM EST

German Court Sides with VW Diesel Owners on Compensation

Court allows buybacks on diesels rigged to evade pollution standards.
#emissions #Volkswagen #europe


Facebook Share Icon LinkedIn Share Icon Twitter Share Icon Share by EMail icon Print Icon

Volkswagen’s never-ending diesel emission scandal just came home to roost.

Germany’s highest civil court ruled today that owners are entitled to compensation for diesels that VW rigged to evade emission limits for oxides of nitrogen.

 Image: VW

The ruling allows owners to return affected vehicles for a partial refund, Reuters reports. The news service says the court’s buyback decision will serve as a template for some 60,000 individual complaints filed in lower German courts.

Different Strategies

VW’s cheating was revealed in the U.S. September 2015, and regulators promptly banned affected cars. Owners quickly sued VW for damages of lost use and value. The carmaker ended up compensating some owners and buying back vehicles from others as part of a $15.3 billion settlement in 2017.

In Europe, regulators didn’t ban the rogue diesels. But they did fine VW and order it to update engine control software, thereby lowering NOx emissions in 8.5 million diesels in Europe.

VW, which complied with all regulatory orders, has insisted that owners have no case because they never lost the use of their vehicles. But the company also has pledged to work with affected owners on a vehicle buyback plan under the new court ruling.

How Much Will It Cost?

VW has paid out some $30 billion in fines, compensation and environmental restitution for the diesel cheating, most of it in the U.S., to date.

One of VW’s 4-cylinder diesel engines  (Image: VW)

The company hasn’t said how much the new ruling could cost. But Reuters notes that a lower court in Germany had ruled previously that an owner was entitled to 80% of the original €31,500 ($34,300) purchase price of a used vehicle he bought in 2014.

The German high court says it has “in principle confirmed the verdict” of the lower court.

VW tells Reuters that it faces more than 100,000 similar damage claims by owners elsewhere across Europe. About 90,000 of those cases are part of a class action-type lawsuit filed in December in the U.K.

More to Come

Separately, VW says it has set aside €830 million ($904 million) to settle a similar aggregated complaint on behalf of 400,000 diesel owners in Germany.

The company tells Reuters that it also has paid out €750 million ($817 million) to settle 200,000 individual damage claims by owners who opted out of the pending group lawsuit.


  • Nio Plant Venture Lands $1.5 Billion Investment

    Chinese electric-car startup Nio Inc. is forming a manufacturing joint venture with Beijing E-Town International Investment and Development Co., which is investing 10 billion yuan ($1.5 billion) in the business.

  • Can You Glue A Car Together?

    I'm not talking about a plastic Revell model of a '57 Chevy, but a real vehicle, one that rolls off an assembly line in 1999 with another 99,999 just like it right behind. Is it possible, or is this just a fantasy of the marketing department at Elmer's?

  • RAV4: 4 Things About the Fourth Generation

    Although the RAV4 has plenty of heritage in the small crossover segment, competition has gotten a whole lot tougher, so Toyota has made significant changes to the fourth-generation model.