| 1:03 PM EST

UPDATE: Is Ghosn Correct about Nissan Plot to Oust Him?

Report says executives fretted over would-be merger with Renault
#Nissan #Renault #people


Facebook Share Icon LinkedIn Share Icon Twitter Share Icon Share by EMail icon Print Icon

Carlos Ghosn claims Nissan executives plotted to remove him as chairman. New emails suggest he might be right.

Bloomberg news cites sources and internal emails that show senior Nissan executives were alarmed by Ghosn’s plan to more closely meld their company with Renault, its 20-year-old alliance partner. Doing so, they fretted, would strip Nissan of the remains of its autonomy.

Nissan describes the emails cited by Bloomberg as “forged or falsified” by Ghosn supporters, who have been circulating them to numerous news outlets over the past several months. Bloomberg, which also spoke to unidentified sources at Nissan, stands by its reporting.

10-Month Campaign

The news service says concerns among Nissan’s top executives about a possible merger with Renault prompted a 10-month-long “methodical campaign to remove a powerful executive.”

The effort culminated in November 2018, when Ghosn was arrested in Tokyo and eventually charged with four counts of misusing corporate funds. Last December he escaped to Lebanon, claiming a fair trial in Japan was impossible and vowing to clear his name.

Hari Nada  (Image: Nissan)

Bloomberg says Nissan’s effort to remove Ghosn was largely led by Hari Nada, then head of Nissan’s chief executive’s office. Hara headed the carmaker’s internal investigation into Ghosn’s activities.

 In April 2018, Nada warned then-CEO Hiroto Saikawa that Ghosn’s merger plans could “create a major disruption and you may become of victim of it.” (Saikawa was later squeezed out over Nissan’s deteriorating financial performance and lack of financial oversight.)

Nada also emailed the head of Nissan government relations to suggest that the company “neutralize [Ghosn’s] initiatives before it’s too late.”

Saber Rattling

Nada further urged that his investigation be broadened to include more serious breach-of-trust claims, the emails and Bloomberg sources say. The news service says Nada added that the charges be “supported by [a] media campaign for insurance of destroying [Ghosn’s] reputation hard enough.”

Days before Ghosn’s arrest, Nada fired off a memo to Saikawa urging that Nissan scrap terms of the alliance agreement, thereby ending France’s ability to nominate senior Nissan executives and freeing Nissan to hike its stake in Renault or even take control of the French company.

Nissan had been simmering for years about the unbalanced equity terms of its alliance with Renault. The partnership gives Renault 43% voting interest in Nissan which, in return has a 15% nonvoting stake in Renault.

The French government owns 15% of Renault but has double voting rights. The state has periodically injected itself into business decisions for the sake of protecting French interests.

Stress and Strain

Not surprisingly, the Ghosn debacle has severely strained the Renault-Nissan alliance. It hasn’t helped Nissan’s sliding financial and sales performance either.

Last month Nissan reported a $5.6 billion net loss, its first in more than a decade, as vehicle sales fell 11%. New CEO Makoto Uchida unveiled a draconian turnaround plan to cut capacity 20%, slash fixed costs by $2.8 billion and narrow its product lineup by 20%.

Even so, Renault—which is struggling with its own financial woes—and Nissan insist they are working harder than ever to revive their alliance.

Talk about merging the two companies has been shelved for now. But the health of each partner and their alliance remains unclear.

Related Topics


  • Designing the 2019 Ram 1500

    Ram Truck chief exterior designer Joe Dehner talks about how they’ve developed the all-new pickup. “We’ve been building trucks for over 100 years,” he says. “Best I could come up with is that this is our 15th-generation truck.”  

  • GM Faces Lawsuit Over Faulty 8-Speed Transmission

    A class-action lawsuit has been filed against General Motors Co. over claimed flaws in the company’s 8-speed automatic transmission used in 2015-2019 model rear-drive vehicles.

  • 2019 Lexus ES 350 Introduced

    The Lexus ES sedan is more than just an offering within the company’s lineup.